Sunday Reflections: The Before and The After
One day when I saw her, she was a pregnant 14-year-old. The next day, she was not.
At 22 weeks pregnant her mother took her into the clinic while her 8-year-old sister and 5-year-old brother sat in the car with an aunt eating Cheetos and talking about whatever little kids talk about. They would go home to a house with no electricity and little food. I had taken them food from our church food pantry several times. Their mom had been let go from work. They lived in a very literal and figurative darkness. This moment was the moment that marked her The Before and The After.
I saw her a couple of years later, sitting all alone on a bench in the middle of downtown, smoking a cigarette. I parked my car and sat down beside her for a moment, asking her how she was doing. She was fine she said, happy. I drove away and watched her in my rear view mirror, thinking about how much of the ugly sides of the world she had already seen.
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Another girl I know had a miscarriage at fifteen. Another became a mom at sixteen.
So when people ask me – and they do – why I think there should be sex in teen books, the answer is because some teens DO in fact have sex. Do I think that they should? Not particularly. Do I wish that they weren’t? I do. Do I think that having sex in teen books encourages teens to have sex? I don’t actually.
When I was a teenager, I read Flowers in the Attic. It never once made me think about having sex with my brother. When I was a teenager I read Forever by July Blume. I was still a virgin when I got married at the age of 22. I like to read about plagues and the apocalypse and zombies and serial killers. I have never once considered creating a plague or becoming a serial killer. But I read them because like the characters in the books, I have had my own The Before and The After.
But that girl, sitting on the park bench smoking that cigarette. She understood about The Before and The After. She understood that there are events in life that change you and there is who you were before and who you are now, after. These are not always bad events, but they often are. The first time you have your heart broken. The first time you have sex. Getting married. Having a child. Losing a child. Losing a parent. Divorce.
It’s when you learn that the world is unsafe, unfair, unreliable.
Some people learn it far too early in life. The family that is rocked by the death of a sibling. The friend that is killed in a car accident. That family that has disintegrated. The children that watch one parent abuse another.
For those who haven’t learned it yet, books are the safest way.
I once had a parent come in and tell me she only wanted her 8-year-old daughter to read the classics, like Little Women, because she wanted to make sure she gained a good vocabulary. But the thing is, books are about more than a good vocabulary. You can read a book and see things like relationships in action, decision making and the consequences, and problem solving. In books you read about The Before and The After. And in doing so, you gain a greater insight into the world around you, the people around you. And when you come to your own moment of The Before and The After, whatever it may be, you can know that you’ll get through it because you have walked with the characters in books and time and time again seen that people are resilient, they survive, they find ways to keep afloat when even the heaviest of burdens try to weigh them down.
There may be The Before and The After in your life, there may in fact be many of them, but in books we are reminded that we are not alone. Every soul walking through this life with you to your left and your right has their own moments, their own story, and that is the power of books – we are reminded that we are not alone.
Filed under: Sunday Reflections
About Karen Jensen, MLS
Karen Jensen has been a Teen Services Librarian for almost 30 years. She created TLT in 2011 and is the co-editor of The Whole Library Handbook: Teen Services with Heather Booth (ALA Editions, 2014).
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
SLJ Blog Network
Halloween is Coming: 31 New Books to Celebrate Spookytime
Review of the Day: How It All Ends by Emma Hunsinger
Review | Chickenpox
Talking with the Class of ’99 about Censorship at their School
ADVERTISEMENT
Paige Y. says
Beautifully written. I was also one who wanted to explore the “forbidden” in books but I was not particularly tempted to do so in real life. I also try to explain to parents (and some teachers) that a library strives to meet the needs of everyone it serves, not just the patrons who live ideal lives.
Lauren's Loquacious Lit says
The thing about sex in YA is that sadly a lot of the times when sex IS mentioned, it's to prove a point: She had sex and now she's pregnant. She went out with a guy and he raped her. And while there SHOULD be books about sexual assault and rape, they shouldn't be the ONLY examples of sex that kids see.
One of the things that I loved about the Vampire Academy books is that both Lissa and Rose have positive sex experiences. Lissa has a very nice, loving boyfriend who treats her well and at the time Rose is shocked because she'd always expected to be first. But theway it's written and the way is handled is how you'd WANT your kid to have sex for the first time, regardless of what religious and age values you place on the experience.
When Rose has sex it's the same thing, Dimitri is loving and respectful and treats her well. It's not graphic, there's no discussions of ins and outs and who touched who where and how. But the important part is that Rose felt GOOD about it and I think that that is what's missing from a lot of books.
Kids ARE squeamish about going to their parents for sex advice, especially when it involves their parents discussing their personal experiences. If their parents are refusing to talk about it, or don't present a good example, as many don't, then there needs to be other places where kids can also get positive examples of sex.
Watching the TV show Puberty Blues here in Australia just makes me SO SAD for these girls that pile three or more couples into a panel van and each take turns climbing over the backseat to make their boyfriends happy. And it's very clear that it's about the boyfriends getting theirs after making the girl use a bit of Vaseline and they are TERRIBLE examples of sex and it makes me sad for every girl AND boy that doesn't know better.
Seeing Rose and Dimitri have sex didn't make me want to run off and find a partner but it DID make me wish I could just photocopy hundreds of those pages and give them to people as an example of what to hold up as an example of a healthy relationship and to find more examples and to EXPECT those examples from their sexual partners if and when they decide that's what they want.
Jenn says
Wasn't Rose underage? I didn't see Rose/Dimitri as a positive example at all.
Teen Librarian's Toolbox, Karen says
Yes, Rose is underage and is also a student to Dimitri so there is some definite power imbalance involved. I don't know if I would consider this an example of a healthy relationship. Christie just reread the entire series so maybe she will weigh in.
Teen Librarian's Toolbox, Karen says
Thank you, yes. Compassion and real world enligtenment are definitely some of the goals in telling stories that are different than our own.
Christie says
I haven't seen the movie, but I read the series.
MASSIVE SPOILERS AHEAD:
There is something very wrong with their relationship all the way through. It starts with her being a student and him being a teacher (and yes, there's not that much age difference but still). *HE* backs off from her, and *ROSE* uses Mason to try and get to him, thinking that THAT is a good idea. When that goes wrong (OH, SO WRONG) and then Dmitri goes dark, Rose deserts Lissa (whom she's bonded to) in order to track him down, and then ends up being his blood whore (addicted to the endorphins from his bites, and craving the heavy petting that they're getting into- to Dmitiri's small credit, he won't have sex with her until she turns dark, but he's doing everything in his power to make her turn).
THEN, *Rose* plays with *Adrian's* heart (and I am in love with Adrian) in order to save Dmitiri, and when everything works out hunky-dory for Rose and Dmitiri (only slaps for them being together as teacher/student), *Adrian's* heart is shattered.
SO, while Rose and Lissa DID have good experiences with the SEX, there are HUGE problems with Rose and her LOVE. There are SO MANY other books out there that show both wonderful experiences about sex AND relationships that make this one disintegrate like a staked Striogi.